Reconstruction Debate

Reconstruction:  Were the goals of Reconstruction achieved?

  • Return to union/unity
  • Agree to follow the Constitution
  • Re-establish government
  • Right to vote/equality
  • Rebuild infrastructure & relationships

 

Opening Statements:  Clearly give your “thesis” or claim that you will be attempting to prove.  Outline your arguments, including the stated goals.                                                           

(Liam's Team) 2 minutes

(Mason H's Team) 2 minutes

Evidence presentation (Liam's Team):  Present evidence, in an organized fashion (not a list but a comprehensive argument to prove your point), with analysis of the evidence—link it back to your thesis “this demonstrates that goals were/were not achieved b/c…

5 minutes

Questions (Mason's Team):  ask questions of (Liam's Team) to clarify claims made/evidence offered?

2 minutes

Evidence presentation (Mason's Team):  Present evidence, in an organized fashion (not a list but a comprehensive argument to prove your point), with analysis of the evidence—link it back to your thesis “this demonstrates that goals were/were not achieved b/c…

5 minutes

Questions (Liam's Team):  ask questions of (Mason's Team) to clarify claims made/evidence offered?

2 minutes

 

Rebuttal preparation:  use time to create arguments to counter/discredit/disprove claims by opponent

4 minutes

 

Rebuttal speech (Mason's Team):  present arguments to counter/discredit/disprove claims by opponent

2 minutes

Rebuttal speech (Liam's Team):  present arguments to counter/discredit/disprove claims by opponent

2 minutes

Closing Statement preparation:  add whatever details are relevant from the debate to your prepared closing argument.

2 minutes

 

Closing Statements:  Summarize evidence and explain how it supports your thesis/claim

(Liam's Team) 2 minutes

(Mason's Team) 2 minutes